14 Comments
User's avatar
Ian Mark Sirota's avatar

The United States of America: A country where it is far easier to get a book banned than it is to enact any law restricting gun sales and/or use.

If that isn't the most damning indictment of our society now, I don't know what is.

Expand full comment
User's avatar
Comment deleted
Dec 1, 2021
Comment deleted
Expand full comment
Ian Mark Sirota's avatar

None as of yet (as far as I know), but as Judd's piece makes clear, I think that it's only a matter of time.

https://www.cbsnews.com/news/banned-books-beloved-controversy-critical-race-theory/

Expand full comment
Jake G.'s avatar

Can we start calling "Moms for Liberty" what they really are? How about "Moms For Racism" because that's really what they're about. I'm so sick and tired of reading about how white racists are trying to turn back the hands of time. I don't understand why teaching history the way it actually happened is such a hard concept. Serious question: wouldn't the Moms for Liberty preferred text also be banned under the current CRT law? It's too traumatizing for a white kid to read about how another white person sprayed black people with a fire hose but it's ok for a black kid to read about other black people were referred to as "pickaninnies"? Are we living in some alternate reality where these white racists think they're the real victims of racism? I am so sick of our current climate and I don't see it getting better any time soon.

Expand full comment
Sheri's avatar

I agree! We need to call them what they are Racist and what they want to do white wash everything!

Expand full comment
Sheri's avatar

It's not "moms for liberty" it's "daughters of the confederacy" next generation 🙄😡

Expand full comment
Tiff C.'s avatar

I have to take a walk before I can even respond to this in complete sentences.

Expand full comment
Justin Weaver's avatar

Those who forget history are doomed to repeat it.

If mankind can't keep that simple guiding principle in their mind, do we deserve better? The human race makes me ashamed.

Expand full comment
Linda Lutz's avatar

The complaint department at the Tennessee BOE is going to be mighty busy during Black History Month. Or...the opposite. Tennessee will probably just ignore it altogether.

Expand full comment
PoetryIsDemocracy's avatar

Wow, somehow I missed this column until I saw the link in todays piece about DeSantis’ proposed propaganda, I mean legislation. Kinda important to read them in sequence. Amazing reporting/writing, thank you Judd & co!

Expand full comment
PoetryIsDemocracy's avatar

Wow, somehow I missed this column until I saw the link in todays piece about DeSantis’ proposed propaganda, I mean legislation. Kinda important to read them in sequence. Amazing reporting/writing, thank you Judd & co!

Expand full comment
VALERIE MELUSKEY's avatar

Thank you for what true journalism should be, and why does it produce excruciatingly painful feelings in this reader? I'm never surprised that conditions are worse than I imagined, but the depths you discover could wake us all up if we have the courage. On that note, we can understand why people project their inner hatred and insanity on to others. And, why revealing this barely hidden malevolence remains important. It's there for all of us to deal with. Thank you, Judd!

Expand full comment
User's avatar
Comment deleted
Dec 1, 2021
Comment deleted
Expand full comment
VALERIE MELUSKEY's avatar

Interesting that my reading of Ta Nehisi Coates is so different from yours. I'll never forget hIs story of Prince Carmen Jones. The irony (or not) that he was gunned down by an obese black police officer who went way out of his way to target and kill this true prince of a man illustrates the lack of safety and justice in the world he knows well. [coda, the 9-11 first responder police and firemen deserve our deep respect and appreciation]

Expand full comment
Bill C in SD's avatar

Nice rant...

Expand full comment
Michael Rose's avatar

Wow

Expand full comment