89 Comments

Once we have reduced every American worker's salary to a point where they can no longer afford to buy our merchandise without governmental assistance, our goals will have been accomplished.

Dollar General /s

Expand full comment

And yet I'll bet it's likely the majority of Dollar Stores employees are Trump supporters.

Expand full comment

I'm not going to bet on that one. It's a foregone conclusion yes? Perhaps not in the most sectors of a city, but in the rural sections of the country? Have no fear, MAGA is here!

Expand full comment

That would not be true in the area where I live, and the stores I have shopped in. I talk to the employees (not about politics, but I get a sense of them). By the way back when Covid19 hit, supermarkets ran out of toilet paper--Dollar Stores were the only place to buy toilet paper. I used to thank them for being there...

Expand full comment

Adam, prize winning comment of the day! 👍🏼

Expand full comment

Shhhh. You gonna get me in trouble!

Expand full comment

I live in Georgia and as I travel into the rural areas the Dollar Store model is everywhere. And they are always busy. These people are ignored by retail and fast food options…and Dollar General saw the opportunity. DG has a captive audience and the outside world doesn’t understand what slimy tactics they are using against their customers and employees. Thanks again for shining the flashlight into the dark corners. Wasn’t David Perdue the former CEO?

Expand full comment

Thanks for the link. Sadly, no surprise that Perdue would be finding ways to increase reprehensible and inhumane selfishness.

Expand full comment

Wow. Good info.

Expand full comment

Our rural town in northern NY is the perfect example. We have two retail choices, a gasoline/convenience store and Dollar General and two small hardware/ag outlets. The next closest markets are 18 miles and 17 miles. With limited choices, DG gets a significant amount of business. You do what you have to do.

Expand full comment

I agree.

Expand full comment

Really seems like a microcosm of the state of American labor today.

Expand full comment

That is why it isn't funny even though I tried to express my sentiment in a humorous manner.

Expand full comment

Living in a rural area, we have 4 in our big county. Truth about the merch is most always in the smaller store aisles. Usually 2 employees on duty. We have 2 Dollar General Markets Ala groceries, too. On Mondays, I can get discounted meats. Bought a $20 roast for $10 and I can get 5 chicken thighs for $2.50.

The point of this is they fill a need and they save folks money during hard times. I can boycott Kroger more easily as they don't do much to save me money. Those same thighs are $6.99.

I agree they should do more for employees. Every corporation could. They put in self checkouts just like the rest. However. The cost of gas is real. Most of the employees here live close to the store. I have asked in my friendly banter. They are not driving 25 to 30 miles each way to the city to work. DG found their nitch. Love them or hate them, the rural areas are greater in size in American miles than the cities. Food deserts are real in rural areas. Poor huddled masses especially Seniors like me, enjoy the $5 big pack of toilet paper and my cheap chicken and a short drive to get them.

Such is life in the sticks around the US.

Thanks for the story.

Expand full comment

My hometown is WAY more rural than what you describe. Why aren’t you organized for a co-op? You don’t have farmers? A freezer? Do you know how to can food? Or use a food dehydrator? When elderly in MY RURAL AREA need to see a specialty doctor, they have to travel (on heavy winter roads) to places between 1-2.5 hours away --Utica or Syracuse, so imagine THEIR GAS COSTS. Even the elderly have to climb up onto the roof to shovel snow. Rather than pointing fingers, you should focus on solutions. We all should.

Expand full comment

I bet you don’t realize that you come across as lecturing others and quite arrogant.

Expand full comment

REALLY? Like that isn't the definition of anti-intellectualists. If you don't like what I have to say - then don't read anything I post.

By the way - LOVE the "quite" arrogant. Why don't you just call me a b***tch and call it a day.

Here's the thing - I don't care what your opinion is of me. I don't take ANYTHING anyone says personally. EVER. This is ALL you - so, if you feel threatened, demeaned, or intimidated - ALL YOU. Have fun trolling - and carry on!

https://www.studioatao.org/post/understanding-anti-intellectualism-in-the-u-s

Anti-intellectualism is often misunderstood as mere hostility towards acquiring knowledge, or the byproduct of the lack of a formal education. However, this definition ignores how anti-intellectualism has been wielded by those with power, as a means to uphold the ideas and systems that benefit them, and thus enabling the continued expansion of these attitudes through society over time.

Expand full comment

My comment was about Dawna...

Expand full comment

Even so, not cool. Don't read the posts or move on. I don't agree with everything I read here. If I don't find something of value to me - then it is my responsibility to "privately" question that person. Not openly judge someone who, as we all are, desperately trying to conquer the misinformation, hate, and challenges that Racism, Fascism, and collective narcissism have done to destroy us - and our planet.

We should be supporting each other here - in any way we can. Even if that means being uncomfortable with someone else's opinions or ideas.

I don't always get it right - but we would all like to be given the opportunity to have our voices heard and hope that we can make a difference.

I've been in this fight since the 60's - and believe me, I'm old and tired.

We have got to teach our children and their children how to collaborate, questions, and respect our differences - because our fight is their fight.

And our lives depend on it.

Expand full comment

Well said. Couldn't agree more.

Expand full comment

It seemed to me that Cathy had solutions. You are too critical. I am a senior in a rural area with a garden and a canner and snow shovels. DG still fills voids. Stop the judging.

Expand full comment

Our story precisely, minus the fresh food.

Expand full comment

I grow veggies and freeze them. I recycle jars and tubs and bread bags for storage purposes, too. My parents were Depression Era.

Got 5 big Tyson chicken thighs this morning marked down for $2.63 DG market. Temptations chicken kitty treats marked down to $1. You do what you have to do is right.

Expand full comment

This is the libertarian free market Milton Friedman philosophy of how companies should be allowed to run.

Expand full comment

The only form of protest I have against corporations, like Home Depot, Hobby Lobby, Dollar General, Kroger, Chick-fil-A, etc., is to spend my money elsewhere. I choose companies that treat their employees fairly and avoid involvement in religious or political matters.

Expand full comment

Which is why I won’t go to those stores, owned by the most egregious, fascist billionaires of the Charles KKKoch Gang--Home Depot, Hobby Lobby, Chick-fil-a, Dollar General--Nope, nope, nope, nope. Unfortunately, Kroger is literally a conglomérate EVERYWHERE. . . AND growing. That is a big problem.

Expand full comment

Kroger employees filed suit against the company in January alleging wage theft. This is an ongoing issue with Kroger and it’s subsidiaries. I avoid their stores like the plague.

Expand full comment

If there is a chain grocery store outlet--like Hy-Vee or Bakers, Kroger crowds into the shelves. The quality is poor, too, so I try to get other brands, albeit more expensive. Boycotting is a price we have to pay for a democratic government strangled by corporate greed.

Expand full comment

I shop at Aldi and Costco here in South Carolina. Both take good care of their employees by providing above-average wages, excellent healthcare, and company-sponsored retirement plans. I work for Costco so I have first-hand knowledge of their pay and benefits.

Expand full comment

What about Trader Joe's and LIDL? They both seem to treat their employees well, and their prices and quality offer good choices.

Expand full comment

I like Trader Joe's and Whole Foods. I agree, they both seem to take good care of their employees. Would shop with them, just don't have either near me!

Expand full comment

And you're not wrong about the stranglehold greed has on all aspects of our daily life!

Expand full comment

Dawna, we don’t have a Kroger within reasonable driving distance to us. We do, however, have a HyVee. We very rural, small town living, population 7600. I don't buy store brands, never have.

Expand full comment

There is a reason that RePUGS hate unions. “Trickle down economics makes Peons of us all.” If the only solution is a shitty Dollar Store, than make new solutions. Develop Co-Ops. Strike/ boycott. Use postal services. Whatever they do, don’t just sit in front of a Fox station and commiserate in a Repug Pity Party of entitlement and victimization. Rise UP. Be a damned community. IT TAKES A VILLAGE.

Expand full comment

The folks who shop there are too busy trying to live and they don't all sit in front of Fox every night. If you want to rise up, go for it. I'll put my time and money into trying to keep Democracy going. My cheap chicken price contributes to my causes.

Expand full comment

During the Great Depression, people raised their own chickens. And commerce included trading chickens and eggs. Maybe you should try it. There are plenty of people who do that, even in medium-sized cities like mine. And I bet you don’t have much of a winter. You could even do a square-foot garden on raised beds.

Expand full comment

I shared the link to Judd's story on the Dollar General Facebook page (in the comments of one of their posts). Perhaps others can as well.

Expand full comment

This is a tough one. In a perfect world, Dollar General would perform the desired corrections with a smile and an apology. It is not a perfect world. Dollar General provides a service that very few other companies offer. In the real world, this allows them to become a "Colonel Jessup" company. Paraphrased below.

"I have neither the time nor the inclination to explain myself to a man who rises and sleeps under the blanket of the very freedom that I provide, and then questions the manner in which I provide it! I would rather you just said "thank you" and went on your way..."

Can a replacement or competitor company offer better service, employee compensation and employee work environment while providing the public the same price points and providing the owners reasonable profits?

Dollar General has competition in suburban areas, but not so much in food scarce areas. I believe there is a reason for that.

Someone smarter than I am needs to build a better mouse trap.

Anyone who wants to penalize me 15 yards for using too many metaphors, go ahead. :-)

Expand full comment

One competitor strategy could be to be less greedy at the C Suite level and pass those savings down.

Expand full comment

Precisely. Instead of undercutting the competition and keeping the profits, undercutting the competition and sharing out a generous portion of the profits in the form of customeer savings, would build brand loyalty unlike any other.

Expand full comment

Oh, if only the corporations in our "Capitalist" country could be less greedy (and pass those savings down), we'd have a kinder gentler world and less inflation to boot!

Expand full comment

Indeed. But that would be too much like "socialism!" Amirite?

Expand full comment

This is shameful and unethical. How can we or Congress put more teeth into OSHA fines to make it hurt this and any other company that starves its personnel while the CEO waltzes off with Million$? Disgusting; thanks for this story, Judd.

Expand full comment

I can proudly say I have never and will never enter a Dollar Store. Now, I think this article needs to be available to the communities that patronize such establishments--give them something factual to pin their discontent, instead of the faux, BS, Repug,Fox inventory of blame. You get what you vote for, People.

Expand full comment

I think you need to live in a rural area and have limited options and funds. You just might. Every corporation we use has dirty hands of some sort, of that I am sure. Capitalism is dirty, always has been. An unfortunate side to why 'Merica is in the shape it is in.

Expand full comment

I grew up in THE POOREST rural area of NY state--a place that used to be proud of its independence and problem-solving. Now, its full of mind-addled trumpanzees and drug users. Their representative is Elise Stefanik, a token female, attention whore for the Repug party. The chain stores left Lowville; people travel an hour to Utica/Rome for their groceries OR THEY GROW THEIR OWN AND CAN ENOUGH FOR THE WINTER--and winter is a 9-month ordeal with THE HIGHEST SNOWFALL IN THE LOWER 48. So don’t preach about poor, pitiful, rural circumstance to me, Cathy B.

Expand full comment

See my thoughts from above…

Expand full comment

You can't always grow your own food and unfortunately there are plenty of poor people of people to go round. I live in Appalachia. You stay in your lane. I will be in mine with my right turn signal going in to Dollar General.

You go rise up with all the perfect corporations you I patronize

Expand full comment

But what if Dollar General is the only option? This point is made clear in the report.

Expand full comment

People need to set limits. Rise up. As it stands, they are a model of the coal miners’ “company town.” I remember when people would unite and do the hard thing in order to achieve equality in the south. RISE UP. Quit taking shit. Find solutions.

Expand full comment

Keep in mind that Dollar General is different from Dollar Tree and Family Dollar.

Expand full comment

Dollar Tree now owns Family Dollar so it's a duopoly with Dollar Tree and Dollar General.

Expand full comment

Sure enough, since 2014.

Expand full comment

Are they really? This is an honest question as I thought they all eroded choice with their business tactics by underselling all the Mom & Pop stores in an area until they close.

Expand full comment

By different, I mean different businesses. They may all be equally sleazy, I don’t know.

Expand full comment

Got it. I think they are all equally sleazy. Just an opinion mind you.

Expand full comment

There is a DG less than 3 miles from me. I stopped shopping there although their brand name paper goods are very low cost and affordable, and came in handy when I ran out of milk, butter or cheese. I stopped going exactly for the reason the article quotes. 1-2 employees only who although very nice to customers, couldn't manage the clutter.

Expand full comment

Unregulated capitalism is a rigged game. Dollar General is the poster child for anemic regulation and paltry fines compared to its profits.

Expand full comment

The U.S. "free market", where tax payers subsidize the labor force wages... that actually has a different name as an economic system, but in this backwards nation corporate socialism is allowed to just be labeled something else entirely.

Expand full comment

Yes. Again my mantra: profits privatized, costs socialized. This has become our capitalist system throughout all sectors of the economy.

Expand full comment

The article on murders I mentioned above is free on ProPublica. Just search for “Dollar General murder”. It also found that the murder problem is specific to Dollar General; it for NOT happen at Dollar Tree or Family Dollar, their two big rivals. I don’t know if that is also true of wage theft and on-the-job accidents.

But I agree with Cathy b. That a consumer boycott is not the answer. More rigorous law enforcement would be more effective.

Expand full comment

And it's not just Dollar General. Just another part of the dismantling of human rights and democracy.

https://www.law.berkeley.edu/article/subminimum-wage-violates-international-human-rights-standards/

At a packed law school event last week, the report’s co-authors cited numerous U.S. breaches of international agreements designed to protect workers’ access to a living wage, along with basic needs such as food, healthcare and housing. The U.S. is a signatory to most of these accords, but has not ratified all of them, which means they’re not legally binding.

The failure to abide by these international standards, while keeping subminimum wage laws intact, “exposes the gap between our democratic values and what our laws and regulations actually do in practice,” said Clinical Professor Laurel Fletcher, director of IHRLC.

Expand full comment

Two things that I think are key:

1. Employers are constantly making wage errors & no one is aware. Sometimes it results in over payments but more often it’s wage theft. There are few checks & balances and companies are not incentivized to avoid errors.

2. Minimum wage used to indicate the job was meant for a new worker for training purposes - or a student earning money on the side while completing their studies. Now, minimum wage is for the poorest workers and it needs to be adjusted to a more livable wage. In SF, the minimum wage is over $17/hr but few people (& no families) can live in SF on $36k annually. Housing alone is equivalent to $36k Ann and likely much more.

Expand full comment

I agree. I've been involved in Sarbanes Oxley audits - and payroll is miserable (and complicated). And, the rules change - now, sick leave is PTO. Can't we have both? And there are other issues. Salaried workers being mis-categorized so they don't have to pay overtime. And complaints to the State Labor Boards don't accomplish anything. You're on your own, unless it's a big enough violation you can get a Labor Attorney involved. Good luck with that.

And minimum wage in the 60's wasn't that awful compared to "real" wages. If you made $3.00 per hour and the Manager made $5.00 per hour - not so heinous. When I see the stats on how much you have to make now just to eek by it's just mind numbing.

The only other issue I see is that even illegals, mowing lawns are making upwards of $15 an hour in some places in Florida. So, that really hurts the low-end service people.

It's getting tough out there.

Expand full comment