Re private equity and hospitals, time and time again, the story is one of putting profits over people, as this piece helps elucidate. I'm glad there are legislative efforts to rein in the takeover. Once the newly-elected are sworn in, Democrats have a real opportunity here for a win if they're willing to take it.
Wow! I live in an area where our once county owned major trauma center hospital was bought by HCA. It is a disaster. HCA understaffs to the point that the hospital has been under almost constant “ immediate jeopardy” orders since the takeover. HCA has closed the labor and delivery departments in several of the rural satellite hospitals, causing women in labor to drive over an hour over mountain roads in bad weather to access care. This is in direct violation of the original agreement when they bought the hospital.
Most of the surgeons that made this hospital one of the best in the Southeast have moved elsewhere. The entire Neurology department walked out. The cancer care unit left. The hospital is being sued by several families whose family members died as a result of inadequate care. The State Attorney General has brought suit against them for breaches of contract among other things.
The staff is now majority made up of “travelers” ….Doctors and nurses who are not from this community, but travel to whatever of these for profit hospitals are paying the most. Anyone who needs emergency care takes the risk of driving to neighboring communities rather than go to HCA.
To be an annoying contrarian, I wouldn’t mind hearing the things that do well when PE takes over. Quality of care might increase. Lots of downsides I read here and don’t dispute.
I put AI to work and the best it could come up with is…examples of hospitals in financial distress (not for profit) that PE bought. So you’d be left with no hospital if no for-profit entity had bought them. But in all cases, patient happiness fell. And quality of care though was mixed - not a clear indication you always get more infections, accidents or death.
Quality of care does NOT improve, as studies show. Patients have fewer staff, doctors, and nurses to attend to them and corners are cut on other resources as well. Annoying contrarian, go the FUCK back to sleep.
They don't care about health care or human life. An investment company's executive take no oath to do so. All they care about is money. Look at the track record » prisons, private housing, veterinarians, hospitals. After infiltrating, they inflated all these industries, so people are suffering, dying, homeless, bankrupt, animals being euthanized instead of adopted. It's sad how the 24/7 news cycle (by its telling both sides) has brainwashed people into believing there is “good on both sides”. Greed is the opposite of good.
Private equity firms are predators, soaring over the business world, looking for carrion to pick at, and devour the entrails of, while leaving the husk of the prey lying in the sun to rot. Shameful billionaires and the millionaires who worship them do not give an actual fuck about your grandma suffering or your child dying, they care about the bottom line and left empathy far behind. And Congress"lags" behind... and care falls off...and doctors leave failing hospitals. What a great country!
Our local dentist office was purchased by private equity. It was strung together with several other area small practices (sold to us as convenient, multi office locations) and over a couple of years time, the staff turnover, the constant requests for payment (that we had already made) and billing opacity that wasted our time straightening out, big cost increases for basic care and the last straw, being left in the lurch with severe tooth pain requiring urgent care when my face blew up, we decided to vote with our feet and found another dental practice 35 miles away. Very happy with the change. We hadn't realized the slow grinding aggravations that we were enduring. Similar story with a veterinary clinic as well. Private equity makes EVERYTHING worse. EVERYTHING!
Also our state (CT) was the first in the nation to ban private equity's purchase or hospital lease backs after a disastrous hospital bankruptcy after private equity had ravaged it in the western (poorer) part of the state.
Judd, Absolutely one of the urgent reporting on private equity firms. The corporate raiders of today. Joseph Mangano Right On!
Private Equity firms need to be taxed far greater than they are now. From the housing shortage to hospitals, and more. Sucking the life out of anything just for greed!
So private equity is intent on killing people - in hospitals and nursing homes. Is there a foothold in the prediction market industry as to how many of us they will kill ?
Thank you for the reporting, disgusting and dystopia as the practices are, we must change them.
Any bill that restricts or Denys Medicare coverage to for profit hospitals punishes patients more than it does the greedy stockholders. The hospitals will just hound sick people for their fees.
Do you think that Medicare For All would solve these problems? If health care were free, that would completely eliminate the financial incentives for both hospitals and private equity. They're using our medical needs as their cash cow.
We could--and I believe ought to--have the best medical care in the world.
As to paying for it, we're already paying for it. We're just not getting much.
Medicare for all is probably the sanest and most reliable way to transition out of the current for profit system, but make no mistake, it is not "free". our taxes will go up to pay for the health care. What it WILL do is cut out the profits that health insurers are now raking off of us for health care. It will relieve hospitals and Doctor's practices from having to hire legions of staff to deal with the various Health insurance companies in order to get paid for their services. It will help control costs, and particularly if Medications and dental/eyecare are included.
It will relieve employers of the burden of searching annually for a policy that covers their employees adequately, and will provide health coverage for small businesses who are shut out of finding coverage for their employees because the health insurers are too GD greedy to deal with them.
And the prime benefit is that Americans will join the rest of the civilized world in knowing that if we fall ill, we will have access to healthcare without bankrupting ourselves and our family.
I have yet to see private equity actually "run" anything. They are extractive capitalist enterprises whose nominal activities (veterinary, hospital, or what have you) are incidental the extraction of wealth. If they can't get more out of an enterprise than they put in they look for a different enterprise. Of course these organizations impoverish communities!
The costs of vet care since the PE buy out is making it too expensive to have pets anymore. Animals suffer because owners can’t afford to take them to the vet.
The numbers you've provided in this article are almost too difficult for the average American to wrap his/her head around. Numbers we’re not a part of. I personally don’t think private equity firms should be allowed to invest in medical AT ALL.
Even when hospitals are run by non-profits, there are problems. They need to be run as independent public institutions like small utilities with local boards and tons of daylight on finances. Zero room for Wall Street. I'm still looking for one PE fan to explain how patients benefit from this
It was our local board…..under the influence of the overpaid administrator, who had already secured a cushy job with HCA before the deal was done….that agreed to this sale to HCA. There were other legitimate bidders who would have been many degrees better than this bunch of vultures. There is so much wrong with this entire transaction that the incompetence ( ? ) of the local board combined with the greed of everyone involved is heartbreaking.
Excellent piece. Made me curious, so I looked up the status in MN, where I live. While we dont have any hospitals owned by PE, we do have clinics owned by private equity. Thanks for surfacing this issue. On a side note, this is also happening in Manufactured Home Parks across the nation. People are being priced out of the land they "rent". It's all BS!
Reveal had done a very well researched podcast (with the help of Mother Jones which publishes excellent investigative pieces) on this very subject and I highly recommend supporting both with subscriptions. Below is a link to one Mother Jones article on the Steward bankruptcy:
“In 2000, private equity firms invested just $5 billion across the entire health care sector. By 2024, that number was $104 billion.” Needless to say they’re making money… sad to say the Democrats are complicit. I’m in MA a very blue state… and there has been a failure in leadership by our Democratic governor, senate & house to take this on … prime example being the Stewart Health Care scandal… and this failure extends as well to seniors healthcare facilities. Money talks and the Blues walk too…
Re private equity and hospitals, time and time again, the story is one of putting profits over people, as this piece helps elucidate. I'm glad there are legislative efforts to rein in the takeover. Once the newly-elected are sworn in, Democrats have a real opportunity here for a win if they're willing to take it.
Wow! I live in an area where our once county owned major trauma center hospital was bought by HCA. It is a disaster. HCA understaffs to the point that the hospital has been under almost constant “ immediate jeopardy” orders since the takeover. HCA has closed the labor and delivery departments in several of the rural satellite hospitals, causing women in labor to drive over an hour over mountain roads in bad weather to access care. This is in direct violation of the original agreement when they bought the hospital.
Most of the surgeons that made this hospital one of the best in the Southeast have moved elsewhere. The entire Neurology department walked out. The cancer care unit left. The hospital is being sued by several families whose family members died as a result of inadequate care. The State Attorney General has brought suit against them for breaches of contract among other things.
The staff is now majority made up of “travelers” ….Doctors and nurses who are not from this community, but travel to whatever of these for profit hospitals are paying the most. Anyone who needs emergency care takes the risk of driving to neighboring communities rather than go to HCA.
To be an annoying contrarian, I wouldn’t mind hearing the things that do well when PE takes over. Quality of care might increase. Lots of downsides I read here and don’t dispute.
If you can cite ONE instance where quality of care has improved, I am sure all of us here would be delighted to hear about it.
It. Does. Not. Happen.
I put AI to work and the best it could come up with is…examples of hospitals in financial distress (not for profit) that PE bought. So you’d be left with no hospital if no for-profit entity had bought them. But in all cases, patient happiness fell. And quality of care though was mixed - not a clear indication you always get more infections, accidents or death.
Quality of care does NOT improve, as studies show. Patients have fewer staff, doctors, and nurses to attend to them and corners are cut on other resources as well. Annoying contrarian, go the FUCK back to sleep.
Thanks. Appreciate the dialogue.
They don't care about health care or human life. An investment company's executive take no oath to do so. All they care about is money. Look at the track record » prisons, private housing, veterinarians, hospitals. After infiltrating, they inflated all these industries, so people are suffering, dying, homeless, bankrupt, animals being euthanized instead of adopted. It's sad how the 24/7 news cycle (by its telling both sides) has brainwashed people into believing there is “good on both sides”. Greed is the opposite of good.
You don’t hear about things done well when prioritizing profits over patient health because nothing is done as well.
Private equity is awful everywhere!
Private equity firms are predators, soaring over the business world, looking for carrion to pick at, and devour the entrails of, while leaving the husk of the prey lying in the sun to rot. Shameful billionaires and the millionaires who worship them do not give an actual fuck about your grandma suffering or your child dying, they care about the bottom line and left empathy far behind. And Congress"lags" behind... and care falls off...and doctors leave failing hospitals. What a great country!
If we're lucky, Chuck will send them a “strongly worded letter”.
Which is why we need new leadership in Congress. This is NOT the time for business as usual. Chuck doesn’t get that.
Totally. The game has completely changed and he's still working by the “strongly worded letter” rules
Our local dentist office was purchased by private equity. It was strung together with several other area small practices (sold to us as convenient, multi office locations) and over a couple of years time, the staff turnover, the constant requests for payment (that we had already made) and billing opacity that wasted our time straightening out, big cost increases for basic care and the last straw, being left in the lurch with severe tooth pain requiring urgent care when my face blew up, we decided to vote with our feet and found another dental practice 35 miles away. Very happy with the change. We hadn't realized the slow grinding aggravations that we were enduring. Similar story with a veterinary clinic as well. Private equity makes EVERYTHING worse. EVERYTHING!
Dentists, Hospitals, veterinary offices,
Doctors practices, Rental agencies,
Real Estate offices,
You name it. The predators are everywhere quietly bleeding all of us dry while they go to their third or fourth “vacation home” in the Bahamas.
Also our state (CT) was the first in the nation to ban private equity's purchase or hospital lease backs after a disastrous hospital bankruptcy after private equity had ravaged it in the western (poorer) part of the state.
Judd, Absolutely one of the urgent reporting on private equity firms. The corporate raiders of today. Joseph Mangano Right On!
Private Equity firms need to be taxed far greater than they are now. From the housing shortage to hospitals, and more. Sucking the life out of anything just for greed!
So private equity is intent on killing people - in hospitals and nursing homes. Is there a foothold in the prediction market industry as to how many of us they will kill ?
Thank you for the reporting, disgusting and dystopia as the practices are, we must change them.
At this point in time, prediction markets are prohibited from wagering on "death" bets. Tune in next week for updates.
Let's all watch what happens to these bills under House and Senate leadership, who have a lot of power to either pursue or bury important legislation.
This is my concern with Jeffries and Schumer, who are so easily bought off by exactly these sorts of interests.
Any bill that restricts or Denys Medicare coverage to for profit hospitals punishes patients more than it does the greedy stockholders. The hospitals will just hound sick people for their fees.
Do you think that Medicare For All would solve these problems? If health care were free, that would completely eliminate the financial incentives for both hospitals and private equity. They're using our medical needs as their cash cow.
We could--and I believe ought to--have the best medical care in the world.
As to paying for it, we're already paying for it. We're just not getting much.
Medicare for all is probably the sanest and most reliable way to transition out of the current for profit system, but make no mistake, it is not "free". our taxes will go up to pay for the health care. What it WILL do is cut out the profits that health insurers are now raking off of us for health care. It will relieve hospitals and Doctor's practices from having to hire legions of staff to deal with the various Health insurance companies in order to get paid for their services. It will help control costs, and particularly if Medications and dental/eyecare are included.
It will relieve employers of the burden of searching annually for a policy that covers their employees adequately, and will provide health coverage for small businesses who are shut out of finding coverage for their employees because the health insurers are too GD greedy to deal with them.
And the prime benefit is that Americans will join the rest of the civilized world in knowing that if we fall ill, we will have access to healthcare without bankrupting ourselves and our family.
Seems like a no-brainer to me.
That's been my impression. Doctors can be doctors again, and not bureaucrats. I (and my family) felt relief when I went on Medicare.
I wonder if this will also affect this giveaway of publicly developed drugs that are granted to private companies for profit as well.
If our new Congress has any sense, this will be one of the first things they take up--after some clean up of the mess and corruption.
In my province (BC, Canada) the provincial government owns and runs the hospitals. They seem to be doing an OK job.
Private equity has bought up veterinarian practices however. According to my niece who worked for one they’re horrible
I have yet to see private equity actually "run" anything. They are extractive capitalist enterprises whose nominal activities (veterinary, hospital, or what have you) are incidental the extraction of wealth. If they can't get more out of an enterprise than they put in they look for a different enterprise. Of course these organizations impoverish communities!
The costs of vet care since the PE buy out is making it too expensive to have pets anymore. Animals suffer because owners can’t afford to take them to the vet.
Amen
Depressing... Private Equity in housing now too.. apartments ..raising rents people will be living on the streets
The numbers you've provided in this article are almost too difficult for the average American to wrap his/her head around. Numbers we’re not a part of. I personally don’t think private equity firms should be allowed to invest in medical AT ALL.
The greed is mindboggling.
No private equity medical, housing or prisons.
Megan Greenwell’s book Bad Company covers the Wyoming hospital saga in great detail. Highly recommended.
Even when hospitals are run by non-profits, there are problems. They need to be run as independent public institutions like small utilities with local boards and tons of daylight on finances. Zero room for Wall Street. I'm still looking for one PE fan to explain how patients benefit from this
It was our local board…..under the influence of the overpaid administrator, who had already secured a cushy job with HCA before the deal was done….that agreed to this sale to HCA. There were other legitimate bidders who would have been many degrees better than this bunch of vultures. There is so much wrong with this entire transaction that the incompetence ( ? ) of the local board combined with the greed of everyone involved is heartbreaking.
The harm that proft maximizing choices and policies inflicts on both staff and patients is far more damaging than immediate deaths.
6 years in prison IF they get caught IF a patient can be proven to have died due to those policies and practices is utterly weak.
Nationalize hospitals.
Excellent piece. Made me curious, so I looked up the status in MN, where I live. While we dont have any hospitals owned by PE, we do have clinics owned by private equity. Thanks for surfacing this issue. On a side note, this is also happening in Manufactured Home Parks across the nation. People are being priced out of the land they "rent". It's all BS!
Thanks PI, great reporting as always. Classic private equity enshittification of America.
Reveal had done a very well researched podcast (with the help of Mother Jones which publishes excellent investigative pieces) on this very subject and I highly recommend supporting both with subscriptions. Below is a link to one Mother Jones article on the Steward bankruptcy:
https://www.motherjones.com/politics/2025/05/steward-health-care-medical-properties-trust-hospitals-bankruptcy-ralph-de-la-torre/
here is a link to the Reveal podcast (transcript available:
https://revealnews.org/podcast/medical-properties-trust-steward-health-hospitals-private-equity/
“In 2000, private equity firms invested just $5 billion across the entire health care sector. By 2024, that number was $104 billion.” Needless to say they’re making money… sad to say the Democrats are complicit. I’m in MA a very blue state… and there has been a failure in leadership by our Democratic governor, senate & house to take this on … prime example being the Stewart Health Care scandal… and this failure extends as well to seniors healthcare facilities. Money talks and the Blues walk too…