167 Comments

It is a crime to make a false police report. “The governor says” does NOT make something pornography. Lock a few of these witches up and it will cool this crap down. This is the stupidest use of law enforcement resources I can think of.

Expand full comment

Well, where I work, during Covid, the rule was to go to an office, you had to be vaccinated. I had several co-workers in Florida use the "My governor said I don't have to be vaccinates and you can't keep me out of the office."

What asshats.

Expand full comment

Jack, Your comment covers what I was going to say. Let’s get the law on these INCITERS and disturbances! In addition, we need witnesses to come forward if these bakeries that refuse service to LGBTQI are serving biblical sinners who have had premarital sex! Sue the bakeries for discrimination at random! Time to turn the tables. I always patronise places that say MAGAs not welcome or Fascists not served. We need to play their game. Wearing a torture devise around your neck? Also known as the cross..don’t serve. Although this is tongue in cheek, we need drastic responses from the public. These librarians must get our protection and the nut cases need to see our wrath!

Expand full comment

I have a bumper sticker that reads:

I READ BANNED BOOKS.

You can get it on t-shirts, too.

Expand full comment

I've got a t-shirt that reads, "I Stand with the Banned" and has a picture of a stack of frequently banned books -- Of Mice and Men, 1984, etc.

Expand full comment

All forms of protest are good! We need to be visible to the public!

Expand full comment

I’ve been meaning to buy one that reads, "I’m with the banned".

Expand full comment

Go for it! I bought three; one for me, one for my daughter, and one for my granddaughter. We wear them when we make a library visit together, but we're lucky - our little library here in Illinois gives out "I Read Banned Books" bumper stickers AND bookmarks!

Expand full comment

I have that one too! A great bumper sticker for sure!

Expand full comment

I agree 100% with you, Jack. As a former librarian, I am just absolutely mortified at these crazy people. It’s shameful that they are doing this.

Expand full comment

As a little side note - throughout jr high and high school I worked in school libraries. Our librarians were the most encouraging people I dealt with. They encouraged students to read everything they could get their hands on.

Expand full comment

Jack, that is the best compliment you could ever give a librarian.

Expand full comment

The Ass-Wipe Floridian Republicans bowed to DeMoron bc he wanted to run for Pres. He is TOAST and needs to quit. he's blowing his donor money and has ZERO chance of WH aspirations. They got on board with this and until stupid Florida voters keep pulling the "R" lever it will get worse. Watch this 2024 session.

Expand full comment

won't happen. They're white

Expand full comment

While these laws are faves of the white christian nationalist movement … prevailing on a false report charge is not that easy. A complaint can be wrong but intent matters. It must be proven to be deliberate. (I see that in FL it is a 1st degree misdemeanor.) This group has access to attorneys & is organized. I think to avoid that charge they bring “evidence” a “buddy” and talk of “wins” in other schools/districts.

Expand full comment

A couple pieces of their approach stood out to me in addition to using a ‘buddy system’ for these complaints. First using the get on the bandwagon thing where they claim to have gotten their way somewhere else. Seems like this is a ploy to give them more credibility. Same story for name dropping the governor & who knows who else.

The second thing is not wanting to press charges and supposedly not wanting to damage anyone’s life (?). That makes me think they are getting a 2fer by going to local law enforcement. A. Possibility of an investigation. B. Issue referred to the school by LEO. Both are for intimidation.

All of it shows methodical planning of this coordinated attack by the self-appointed morality / thought police.

Expand full comment

Yet in Duval County I can't even get the Bible in review. The system is rigged

Expand full comment

I have a friend moving back to Ky soon from FL. She’s lived in FL almost 2 decades and says it is “brutal” under DeSantis. Cross your fingers that our Dem gov prevails in today’s election.

Rigging, bending, pushing the system is the point. The new laws don’t need to go specifically go that far. The strategy in states is to make wording on ed laws sufficiently vague to be taken advantage of by the state, districts, random individuals and threaten those who don’t toe the line. Testing, pushing ignoring federal law. (Similar story with some abortion laws) — This Sheriff sent the issue to the school & they will use the visit to declare victory or war, make claims in some other district raise $$ blah blah.

It is a little weird that Duval ignores issue in the Bible but bans The Berenstain Bears and the Big Question. Intent matters when they walk in these murky areas. You do have allies across the state. https://www.sun-sentinel.com/2023/07/02/could-the-bible-be-the-next-book-banned-in-schools-a-parent-thinks-so/

Expand full comment

You hit the nail on the head! Thank you for sharing this with me!

Expand full comment

Busybodies not only want to control what their kids read, they want to control what your kid reads.

Expand full comment
Nov 6, 2023·edited Nov 6, 2023

Next they'll be going door to door asking folken to "volunteer" to have their books checked for any contraband.

They have to TAKE THEM from my cold, dead, hands. Wait a minute...

Expand full comment

If they come to my door they will find out how a hardcover copy of Ulysses feels as a suppository.

Expand full comment

😂👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻

Expand full comment

Ulysses is only indigestible the first time you read it.

Bulwer Lytton.

Expand full comment

Don't be silly.

We need you.

A nice hard cover copy of War and Peace should knock them out cold.

Then report them for loitering.

Expand full comment

Charlton Heston just rolled over, Adam

Expand full comment

"Moms For Liberty" should change their name to "Busybodies For BS".

Expand full comment

This is such a good point. Their constant overreach and obsession with our children, our bodies. That’s why I wrote the comment about turning the tables on them. They walk around with torture devices! (Crosses)We can scream...terrorist! 😀

Expand full comment

Never thought of that one.

Expand full comment

This is the door opener. They’ve honed their skills, they have a network, more way to control will follow.

Expand full comment

Are you sure they even have kids?

Expand full comment

These folks from Moms for Liberty (a hilarious, self delusional handle if ever there was one) are mentally ill, attention seeking, intellectual midget Karen's of the worst kind. They should be laughed out of every library, school board meeting, and Weight Watchers meeting.

Expand full comment

They are bank rolled by larger conservative groups. They are NOT cupcake crusaders. Think Koch Brothers, Heritage Foundations, The Walton Family.....etc. Seeking Rents did a deep dive into their money pit....READ. EDUCATE!

Expand full comment

Like the Tea Party - Astroturf, not grassroots.

They’ll fit in well with the authoritarian plans of Project 2025.

Expand full comment

Exactly. This is a well funded, pseudo-grass-roots machine, remotely controlled by dark money. Look how fast they came from nowhere!

Expand full comment

Unfortunately they have made strides in book bans, getting elected to office and affecting curriculm. You may think they are ridiculous but they are getting places where the can do plenty of damage. Take them seriously, they are a threat to Democracy.

Expand full comment
founding

Thank you for continuing to call out "moms for liberty" "good Christian women" who want to set back true freedom in our educational system. They're not for freedom--they're for stifling discussions that young people want to have and find beneficial. They are not appreciative of the wise and loving teachings of Jesus--they are judgmental, self-righteous, and fearful. We will be damaged as a wonderful home of the free and the brave if people like Baggett and Tapley [and DeSantis and Mike Johnson (R of Louisiana)] can suffocate our educational system.

Expand full comment

The Bible portrays Jesus fraternizing with Mary Magdalene, a prostitute. Plus the incest, murder, etc. This book should be banned from schools! Someone should ask Moms for Repression about that.

Expand full comment
founding

Yes, but we can hear them rationalize, that like Trump, she was "forgiven." I'd suggest that she was never judged.

Expand full comment

Well said!

Expand full comment

I heard “freedom” by white evangelical nationalist groups only exists in the context of god’s law. Of course they want to be the ones who interpret that.

Expand full comment

"Baggett told Popular Information that she challenged 'When Wilma Rudolph Played Basketball' — the inspirational story of a Black woman who overcame racial prejudice to become an Olympic champion — because it would make white students 'feel uncomfortable' as 'they are being white-shamed.'" Absolutely UNBELIEVABLE!!! This is SO sick. The true story of one person's experience "shames" every white student who reads the book. I'll tell you who should feel ashamed: MOMS FOR LIBERTY!

Expand full comment

I guess Black kids feeling shame all these decades for their ancestors being enslaved is okay. But heaven forbid a White kid feels empathy for anyone else.

Expand full comment

What does it say about a society when a story about a Black kid who succeeds might make white students feel "uncomfortable" and "White-shamed?"

Expand full comment

Lots of bad stuff.

Expand full comment

If they were capable of shame, they wouldn't be harassing librarians.

Anyone who doesn't see Wilma Rudolph as an AMERICAN hero isn't worthy of being an American.

Expand full comment

As always happens with right wing authoritarians, they over-reach, and Karens for Fascism is starting to do that in Floriduh. Time for librarians and others to fight back hard. Sue these assholes for harassment, defamation, or just being assholes. And damn, this woman went thru the book looking for all the "pornography"???? To mark it with sticky notes? Did she have sticky fingers when she was done as well?

Expand full comment
founding

"Karens for Fascism" hits the nail on the head.

Expand full comment

I'm really tired of my name being tied to fascism. Do you realize that some not-so-enlightened people might believe it? Time to move on. If the point can't be made without the use of my name, perhaps there is no point. I speak on behalf of myself only, not the other girls and women named Karen.

Expand full comment

Your point is well taken. In addition there is a small ethnic group of Karen people. I can’t imagine how those who fled to the US think about hearing this.

“The Karen come from the country of Myanmar formerly known as Burma. The Karen are an ethnic group who have resided in Burma for over two thousand years and were one of the first inhabitants of the region. Many of the Karen have fled Burma due to religious and ethnic persecution by the government.”

Expand full comment

I had forgotten that. Thanks for the reminder.

Expand full comment

I agree. Call them what they are. Bitch. The Karen crap is so old and my name isn't Karen.

Expand full comment

That does have a special ring to it Fred. 😀

Expand full comment

I have a dear wonderful friend whose name is Karen. She has a friend who now goes by Kacey instead of Karen (last name starts with a C), because of this meme. How would you like it if your name got attached to stupidity?

Expand full comment
founding

This comment mistakenly got posted below. My mistake.

Try growing up named Fred. (think "The Freeloader." "Flintstone.") Every adult thought they were hilariously original when they called me one of those, and it was my job to act amused or I'd be labeled a rude child. Dumb cartoon characters were named Fred, and some even had the F on their sweatshirt backwards (Super Chicken's sidekick if you're too young to remember).

Expand full comment

The public must loudly support these librarians. What is the best way? Contacting Congress members, State Reps etc. Or take to the streets? These librarians cannot take the burden of this!

Expand full comment

Agreed. Step one, replace local politicians who don't back up the librarians - town boards, city councils, school boards. Time to tell Karens for Fascism to f'k off.

Expand full comment

But Librarians would still be harassed until election time. These Fascist-supporting right wing groups should have the police called on them for intimidation and interference at the job. They need a figurative slap in the face now!

Expand full comment

Sadly in many jurisdictions the cops are just as fascist as the Karens, if not moreso.

Expand full comment
Nov 6, 2023·edited Nov 6, 2023

What a cesspool of ignorance these acts represent. Shocking that this is where we, as a nation, and a species, are at now. I wonder if we are anywhere near to where it will subside, and the First Amendment will garner traction once again. Thanks, Judd.

Expand full comment

VOTE!!!

Expand full comment

Someone needs to tell this woman that if kids really want something "pornographic," there's this thing called the Internet which will readily provide it to them (assuming they have access to a computer or mobile phone). They don't need to go to the school library to do it, never mind that the book she's challenging clearly doesn't qualify.

Expand full comment

Yeah, but these knuckle-draggers have no problem with Matt Gaetz sliming himself onto underaged girls. THAT is gross out pornography. Yuck. Barf. Goosebumps, Ick.

Expand full comment

Or just open the Bible. Mary Magdalene, incest, child murders...

Expand full comment

That struck me as well. The article says there's some making out and a couple almost has sex. I don't know about now, but when I was kid, basically everybody was making out with each other every weekend. The idea that kids aged 14-18 need a book like this to get the idea to make out is just so, so dumb.

Expand full comment

There is a new group similar to MFL active in Chester County PA called Back to Basics. They're running for school board as a candidate block and do their best to come off as fair minded people (spoiler alert, they are not). I'll be showing up to school board meetings and voted to retain our current board, but note these groups are learning to put on a moderate face even in blue counties. Be vigilent!

Expand full comment

Heard. And you have to wonder about the motives of any group that feels the need to pretend in public that they are anything other than what they are.

Expand full comment

False flagging is it's own kind of message and any messenger bearing such tidings needs to be... stopped by any and all appropriate means!

Expand full comment

It astounds me that these people don’t have anything better to do with their time. Imagine if they actually put some of that energy into action that would truly help people.

Expand full comment

Right?? As they love to spit out with venom, “Get a job.”

Expand full comment

Hahahahaha! As long as that job is nowhere near any "kids." You KNOW how those RW'z are around "the children."

Expand full comment

Daughters of the Confederacy = Mom's for Liberty?

"Tapley described Baggett as "a valiant warrior for the kids, an amazing English teacher, and a wonderful Christian woman."

Christians? No! These folken are a sub-species of heretical post-human mutation that one hopes will prove unable to reproduce.

Expand full comment
founding

But they do, have you seen Idiocracy?

Expand full comment

I have. I picture poor Mike Judge rolling his eyes and saying, "Guys! It was a CAUTIONARY TALE, not a GOT-damb INSTRUCTION MANUAL!"

Expand full comment

Unfortunately, I have. Damned prescient too!

Expand full comment

They would be the ones that would build the fire for the witches to be burned for God !

Expand full comment

If this weren’t so dangerous, it’d be down right funny. Personally, I especially liked the part where the informant is angry that there’s a group trying to stop moms for liberty and another trying to protect abortion rights; as if her narrow minded viewpoint is the only one that counts.

Expand full comment

Every town has those people that are attention-seeking, mentally susceptible, and in need of a hobby or friends. With the help of cult leaders like Steve Bannon and hyper sensationalized Facebook posts they are transformed into zealots. The meme about clowns with flame throwers is right on target. I’m sure many of us thought something like this could never happen in our country, but we dumb down our primary education, sanitize it, stop, teaching, civics, and left a whole generation of people who are now adults but who don’t have a grounding in world history, context, and have no idea the fire they’re playing with, or maybe even why they’re doing it.

Expand full comment

Odds are they have no idea how many students in their county schools are able to read at the level these books are written. Low literacy is a major problem in the US among adults and students. Porn in schools? Not a real thing.

National Center for Education study before the pandemic (2012-2017) — According to the study, an estimated 24% of adults in Florida perform at the lowest literacy level and 35% perform at the lowest numeracy level. This puts Florida slightly below the national average on both metrics.

Expand full comment

Scary. Low info voting public is bad news

Expand full comment

Sick people. If they really cared about what is harmful to kids they would be working for gun safety laws.

Expand full comment
founding

Until people call out the Lunacy, publicly, Loudly, and continuously, this Insanity will continue.

Expand full comment

Until these lunatics start going to jail for making false police reports, this insanity will continue.

Expand full comment

I am so sick of these incredibly ignorant people

Expand full comment